我们尝试了邪教美容品牌Glossier的新化妆系列 - 值得吗？

我们在评论中对我们在Instagram feed中看到的那些浮华产品也一样感到好奇。对于我们的“ IG”系列中的“如您所见，我们的作家都会购买它们，并将它们放在他们的步伐上，以找出它们是否真正像他们在线外观一样好 - 或者太好了。我们错过的一个地方？给我们发电子邮件AsSeenOn@reviewed.com。

Back in the summer of 2017, when I was first working in New York City and stressed out of my mind, I became a光泽convert. The now-ubiquitous millennial beauty brand—which got its start on Instagram—is known for its low-effort skincare and no-makeup makeup. It doesn’t just sell products, it sells a lifestyle—one that is decidedly more calm, cool, and beautiful than the one I was living at the time.

I boughtThe Super Packof skin serums to help me look a little more awake,男孩眉头为了取代我一直使用的眉毛眉笔的方式，香脂斑com润唇膏是因为，我很难过，它的味道像生日蛋糕。我什至参观了他们在Soho的旗舰店，并在他们的标志性镜子中拍了一张自拍照，上面写着：“你看起来不错。”我做了！

既然我对护肤的了解更多，并且不需要在每天早上五分钟内准备就绪，那么我将曲目扩展到了Glossier的基础知识之外，并为其自然美容品牌提出了健康的怀疑。他们最近有been criticized for their less-is-more approach，，，，being called makeup for people who are “already beautiful.”

Their response?发挥作用，，，，a new spinoff brand of “dialed-up beauty extras” for those who want their makeup to look like, well, makeup.

什么是Glossier Play？

信用：光泽

与原始品牌不同，Glossier Play是一条充满色彩，闪闪发光和闪耀的美容系列 - 想到70年代的迪斯科会面。他们的核心系列被称为“游乐场”，包括四个主要产品：Colorslide凝胶铅笔眼线笔($15),Niteshine荧光笔($20),Glitter Gelée eyeshadow（$ 14），以及Vinylic Lip lacquer($16).

眼线笔和唇彩具有多种生动，复古风格的阴影，而荧光笔和闪闪发光的阴影具有更标准的金属色。这些产品可通过Glossier的网站专门提供，可以单独购买或作为discounted bundle for $60。

虽然Play的产品回忆起其他品牌的一些通常产品Fenty Beauty和Urban Decay，它们独特的包装，价格相对较低的价格和较高的简单性使它们具有独特的吸引力。是的，大胆的眼线笔和眼睛闪光以前已经完成了，但是可以玩将它们提升到新的水平吗？Glossier向我们发送了各种各样的新产品，因此我们可以自己看到。

将光泽的比赛放在测试中

信用：光泽

虽然简单地穿着所有不同的光泽游戏产品并记下我的想法可能已经足够了休闲美容博客的研究，但这并不是评论的方式，我们全都是关于测试的。因此，在我们的高级科学家朱莉娅（Julia）的帮助下，我开发了一系列测试，以弄清楚这些美容产品的可用，可穿戴，可移动和美丽。

由于这些信息无所作为，所以我研究了哪些品牌的较低和更高的品牌提供的产品与操场上的产品最相似，并选择了两个品牌与Glossier一起测试 -湿n野生（药房）和马克·雅各布斯（Marc Jacobs）美女(luxury). I ordered one to two shades of every comparable product from these brands to see if spending more actually gets you more.

第一个测试涉及在正常一天中孤立地穿着每种产品，并指出如果需要全天重新申请，以及我（和其他人）认为它的外观是多么容易。第二个测试？我将从该品牌的每种产品之一结合在一起，使其在“外出”外观上戴在城镇上。晚餐，饮料，跳舞，你叫它 - 我以科学的名义参加了比赛。

夜晚结束后，我注意到抬头是如何抬起的，以及使我的脸再次清洁有多容易或困难。最后的测试涉及在我的前臂上制作产品的色板，并测量它们干燥的速度，弄脏的程度以及是否防水。

Of course, there’s also the simple question we all ask ourselves when our makeup is done—how do I look? Most of these products are designed to be worn for a good time, not a long time, so I tried to consider their je ne sais quoi along with their objective strengths and weaknesses. Also, certain color palettes appeal to me and my light skin tone more than others, so I let my friend Alex, who has a warmer, medium skin tone, contribute some data by wearing a Glossier Play look on the town, too.

第1轮：眼线笔

图片来源：杰克逊ruckar /审查

Move over, liquid eyeliner—a creamy, blendable version of the classic eyeliner pencil is back in style, and Glossier wants to help you make the switch. We tested发挥作用Colorslide在阴影中，临界质量，火花鲨，现金沙拉，铁杆天鹅绒和花蜜马克·雅各布斯（Marc Jacobs）美女Highliner在蓝色和湿N野生在边缘长衣眼铅笔in To My Yang.

While we were given more shades of Colorslide to test, Marc Jacobs Beauty offers an even greater range of colors to choose from than Glossier Play. The Play collection is more curated, with a funky, matte palette—Marc Jacobs offers the whole rainbow in matte, glitter, and shimmer finishes. Wet n Wild, meanwhile, only offers their longwear pencil eyeliner in five core shades.

我从来都不是眼线笔的粉丝 - 木质，干燥的感觉，涂上如此尖锐的眼睑，一直使我失望 - 因此，我对我喜欢Colorslide的程度感到惊喜。因为它是“凝胶铅笔”，所以它在没有太多的眼睑拉扯或刮擦的情况下滑动，如果您不愿意看不同的线条，则可以混合。

我每天都穿着临界质量阴影独奏，没有发现任何拆卸或剥落，后来将其与花蜜和闪闪发光的鲨鱼融合在一起，以享用晚上。即使它具有防水性，在深夜，它可以轻松脱落，并进行一些卸妆。

Thanks to theGlossier Play Blade(AKA their pencil sharpener), I was able to keep my favorite shades of Colorslide sharp for precise lines. Oddly, many reviews for Colorslide explain that these pencils don’t work well with other sharpeners, so you should spend the $4 on Blade if you’re interested in these liners.

Credit: Cassidy Olsen / Reviewed

I was similarly impressed by Marc Jacobs Beauty Highliner, an even creamier eye pencil that comes in a wide range of shades. My vibrant cobalt blue pencil went on easy and stayed put the entire night, bringing out my eyes and inviting some welcome David Bowie comparisons. Unfortunately, the eyeliner isn’t a true pencil and therefore can’t be sharpened, making it hard to achieve fine lines. This is also true of the Wet n Wild On Edge Longwear Eye Pencil, an otherwise fine product that lasted through testing but didn’t impress with its low pigmentation.

Ultimately, while Marc Jacobs took top marks for pigmentation and creaminess, Glossier Play’s Colorslide was my favorite pencil overall thanks to its versatility and simplicity. It’s not as bold or groundbreaking as Glossier claims, but it’s a great eye pencil for those (like me) who would otherwise stick to liquid.

优胜者：发挥作用Colorslide

Round 2: Liquid Lip Color

图片来源：杰克逊ruckar /审查

液体唇色是一件众所周知的事情，不幸的是，发挥作用’s Vinylic Lip对现有公式的改进并没有太大的作用。我们测试了阴影中的​​粘性，闪亮的产品，婴儿，赌场和小马湿n野生Megalast Liquid Catsuit Metallic Lipstickin I Don’t Dessert You and马克·雅各布斯（Marc Jacobs）美女Enamored Lip Glossin Rah Rah! and Ch-Ch-Changes.

出于各种原因，很难测试和比较。首先，它不能正确地属于“口红”或“唇彩”类别。其细长的标记式包装分配了Doe脚涂抹器的厚实，有光泽的色素化产品，使其成为独特的混合唇色。考虑到这一点，我们选择对传统的液体唇膏和色素化唇彩进行测试。

第一次应用后，我对Vinylic Lip Formula感到非常满意 - 它是光滑，丰富且甜美的，带有Glossier宣传的大胆的色彩。当我试图做其他事情以外，我的经历很快就变化了。只是在房子周围戴上产品，我的手指，脸部，水杯和牛仔裤都在颜色上得到了颜色。

富人的光芒迅速褪色成一种唇彩，难以清除，我厌倦了第二次或第三次重新涂抹。阴影也不适合我的颜色，尽管我没有选择的选择，但它们的粉红色阴影更速度是我的速度。

我也很失望地看到，Vinylic Lip没有在Glossier Play网站和Instagram上宣传的音调或闪闪发光的深度。我没有闪烁，多维唇色，而是注意到具有乳脂状光泽的固体色素沉着。我试图在赌场穿着vinylic唇过晚上，但是当我到达酒吧时，其中大部分已经消失了，我无法重新申请自己。我的朋友亚历克斯（Alex）穿着更微妙的小马，没有抱怨，但也指出了阴影消失了多快。

Credit: Cassidy Olsen / Reviewed

Marc Jacobs Beauty的迷人的唇彩的闪烁，可层的配方比Vinylic Lip更愉快。我选择了白天的雪橇粉红色阴影，并在晚上闪闪发光，虹彩红色，这两者都保持平稳，逐渐消失，而没有弄乱。该配方的色素远不及光泽，但可以单独进行分层，也可以用口红具有更深的颜色。它还具有薄荷味，使我想继续重新涂抹。

湿n野生’s Megalast Liquid Catsuit Metallic Lipstick was—and I can’t emphasize this enough—horrible. Drying, flaky, and difficult to apply, this lipstick completely lacked the shine and smoothness I saw with the other products. My boyfriend actually made of point of saying it looked scary, and that I probably shouldn’t wear it out to drinks. I did anyway, for science, but rubbed it off with a napkin when I caught sight of myself in a spoon. So long, Wet n Wild! Marc Jacobs wins this round.

优胜者：马克·雅各布斯（Marc Jacobs）美女Enamored Lip Gloss

第3轮：液体荧光笔

图片来源：杰克逊ruckar /审查

If reading about the complexity of liquid lip color is making your head spin, welcome to the world of liquid highlighters—shimmery, simple, and overwhelmingly similar. We tested发挥作用Niteshine在苍白的珍珠中，铂金玫瑰和深铜湿n野生MegaGlo Liquid Highlighter玫瑰色，准备好，镀金的光芒，以及马克·雅各布斯（Marc Jacobs）美女Dew Drops Coconut Gel Highlighter在幻想中。

作为已经使用Glossier棒荧光笔的人卤素，我期待尝试Niteshine。少量的浓缩闪光瓶产生了令人愉悦的效果，其颜料比我在卤素中的颜料更多，但并没有从夜间化妆品牌中获得的“哇”因素。

最后，我认为我更喜欢卤素 - 棍棒更容易涂抹，而油性露水的配方对我的钝皮有更多的影响。亚历克斯（Alex）在尼丁（Niteshine）上同样中立，并希望取得更大的影响。

Credit: Alex Mendelsohn / Reviewed

潮湿的n野生MegaGlo液体萤光笔a similar shade range as Niteshine, but each bottle has a thicker, larger applicator that helped me get enough product with one swipe. The formula itself is brighter and more multi-dimensional, and I noticed it still glimmering away on my nose bridge after a full night out.

The Marc Jacobs Beauty Highlighter is more of a bronzer than a true highlighter—the towering, pill-shaped pump bottle full of richly-pigmented formula is best for highlighting summer skin (both face and body) than wearing for a normal night out. It smells absolutely amazing, and I will be using it when I have something of a suntan in a few months, but it’s not in the running for this competition. For a quarter the price of Niteshine, it seems that MegaGlo is the way to go.

优胜者：湿n野生MegaGlo Liquid Highlighter

Round 4: Eye Glitter

图片来源：杰克逊ruckar /审查

最后但并非最不重要的一点是，每个人最喜欢的化妆成分 - glitter！好吧，除了真正关心塑料对环境的影响的人以外。Glossier Play因在他们的Glitter Gelée，用于大胆外观的多功能火花产品。我们在幻象上测试了闪光的凝胶，然后燃烧Marc Jacobs美容See-Quins闪光眼影in Flashlight and湿N野色图标闪光单曲在尖刺和黄铜中。

不幸的是，实际上所有这些产品都包含PET，，，，a common type of plastic. Although the Marc Jacobs product is also mineral-based (and gives off a more natural sparkle), it isn’t guilt-free. If you’re not interested in purchasing products with non-biodegradable plastics, read no further. It’s worth noting that all these Glossier products are pretty heavy on the plastic packaging, but that’s unfortunately still common throughout the beauty industry.

Credit: Cassidy Olsen / Reviewed

Glossier Play的GlitterGelée和Marc Jacobs Beauty See-Quins既有趣又美丽。光泽goes the New Year's Eve route with big, confetti-like pieces of glitter in clear gel bases, whereas Marc Jacobs offers more a more sophisticated, spreadable glimmer with mineral-pigmented formulas.

最后，我更喜欢穿马克·雅各布斯（Marc Jacobs），因为它持续了顺利并轻松脱落 - 几天后，斑点斑点粘在我的水线上。如果您可以忍受塑料，那么您的旋转都有空间。我尝试使用发挥作用Detailerto apply the Glitter Gelée, but ultimately preferred using my fingers.

The messy, gritty, cheap, and difficult Wet n Wild Color Icon Glitter Singles are not even in the running. I unfortunately wore the gold shade out with the very dry Wet n Wild lipstick and looked like a solid mess. I went to a Kesha concert my freshman year of college, and the random pods of glitter I bought on Amazon to wear all over my face and body were still better than these glitter singles. Don’t buy them.

优胜者：Marc Jacobs美容See-Quins闪光眼影

Glossier如何播放？

信用：光泽

For the digital beauty brand’s first venture into makeup-makeup, Glossier Play isn’t half-bad. Their Colorslide eyeliner impressed me with its versatility and ease of use, and I plan to use my Niteshine highlighters and Glitter Gelée eyeshadows again in the future. The only product that truly disappointed me was Vinylic Lip, and I’m already pretty fussy when it comes to lip color.

That being said, there’s a definite disjoint between Glossier Play and the brand’s original, effortless approach to beauty that made me fall in love with them two years ago. To make fuchsia eyeliner and goopy orange lip color work, you need to know what you’re doing and apply your makeup with confidence—you can’t swipe it on, pose in a sunny window, and suddenly look like an Instagram model.

If you’re just dipping your toes into evening makeup, buying aPlayground set在您最喜欢的阴影和熟悉技术的情况下，可靠地使用60美元，但是如果您已经喜欢高影响力的妆容，那么您将最好地投资具有可靠的往绩的单个产品，例如我们来自Marc Jacobs Beauty的最爱。我希望Glossier Play开发的产品比目前的产品更可穿戴，但是在那之前，我很乐意继续用Colorslide来吸引自己。

Get the Glossier Playground Set for $60

The product experts at审查拥有您所有的购物需求。关注审查Facebook，，，，Twitter， 和Instagramfor the latest, deals, product reviews, and more.

Prices are accurate at the time this article was published, but may change over time.

More As Seen On product reviews

• 您能相信您在Instagram上看到的产品吗？
• 我们尝试了金·卡戴珊（Kim Kardashian）的新身体妆容 - 值得炒作吗？
• We tried the personalized shampoo that's all over Instagram—does it work?